Skip to Content

My Failed Twin Breastfeeding Experience…and Why I’m OK With It

Sharing is caring!

When I found out I was expecting twins, I thought I would easily figure out twin breastfeeding.

I breastfed my first, Theo, up until he was about 11 months old. I loved that I was giving him good quality milk, that it was so easy (no bottles to wash, heck yes!), and that it was FREE.

I’m a pretty stubborn individual, and when I set my mind to do something, I usually get it done. I thought that would be the case with breastfeeding twins, but unfortunately, it wasn’t.

twin breastfeeding experience

*Post contains Amazon affiliate links.

My Twin Breastfeeding Experience

My girls were born almost two months early (you can read my birth story here) and started their lives in the NICU.  They received their first feedings via tube, and then gradually were introduced to bottles.

With the help of a lactation consultant, I was able to breastfeed a few times while the girls were in the NICU.  The girls both latched briefly but received more milk through their feeding tube because they didn’t have the strength to nurse for very long.

I was told to give it time by everyone; the doctors, the nurses, the lactation consultants, and even my mom.  Apparently around their due date would be the magical time that they became more alert and would have the strength to exclusively breastfeed.

When we brought the girls home, I was totally content pumping and feeding them. I mean, yes, pumping sucks. Washing bottles and pump parts sucks.  Heating up bottles sucks, figuring out how to heat up bottles on the go sucks, and it all just sucks!

Why I Was OK With Not Breastfeeding My Twins

The girls were gaining weight.  Preemies need SO much sleep and don’t like to wake up to eat.  Both girls were under 5 pounds when we brought them home and we had to work really hard to get them to eat.  It was nice to give them a bottle and know with certainty that they were getting a full feeding.

We were on a routine. Granted, it was a chaotic, exhausting routine, but it was working! We were learning and figuring things out.  (If you have newborn twins at home, you can read about my schedule here.)  When something is working, why change it?

I was overwhelmed.  Being a new twin mom is hard.

Being a new twin mom with a 2-year old at home is even harder.  Being a new twin mom, with a two- year old at home, with 8-week premature babies is something I’m not even sure how I survived.

I remember being so overwhelmed, going through my days just trying to keep everyone fed and in clean diapers.  The thought of learning how to tandem breastfeed was one extra thing that I could not handle.

I did try a few times because I felt like it was the thing I was supposed to do.  I’m not sure if it’s society or other moms, but something makes us feel like we have to breastfeed and anything else is the lesser choice.

So, I had my husband help me raise this teeny, tiny, fragile baby to my breast, and hold her in place. The end result was the baby screaming because she was hungry and didn’t know what to do.

My husband ran to the kitchen to prepare a bottle as I tried not to have a panic attack.  I felt like a failure as a mommy because I couldn’t give my baby milk from my body.

This happened a few times, and then I decided that it was not worth it.  It added an incredible amount of anxiety and stress to an already stressful situation.

(Curious if they’re identical or fraternal twins?  Read this post to find out.)

My Failed Twin Breastfeeding Experience Helped Me Stop Being Judgy

So why am I happy that I failed at twin breastfeeding? Because it has opened up this whole new world of being a non-judgy mom.  In complete, vulnerable honesty, being a judgy mom is something I struggle with.

I didn’t even really know that I was judgy before, and I think that’s exactly the problem.  When I heard of someone doing something different, my instinct was to correct them.  To tell them how my babies thrived sleeping in their own crib or being sleep trained or eating all organic food.

I think it’s important that we acknowledge that this judgy mom lives inside of all of us (I am not the only one!).  Acknowledge her, and then tell her she is not welcome anymore!

The Great Breastfeeding Debate

What do we do with breast is best versus fed is best debate?

I know firsthand that the pressure to breastfeed can cause severe anxiety and depression in moms.

Even innocent comments about breastfeeding or breast is best can place dangerous pressure and stress on moms who struggle with it.  So please heed my empathic words and watch what you say; this coming from a mom who’s been on both sides.

Breastfeeding moms:
  • Don’t say breast is best.  Please, just don’t.
  • Don’t talk in a way that might be perceived as ‘bragging’ to other moms; your milk production, how you exclusively breastfed, etc.
  • Do feed your baby in public, with or without a cover, whenever they are hungry.  That is your right, and it is beautiful.

This is a beautiful post, written by a lactation consultant, on the same topic.

A quote from the article:

“But it is not up to anyone but that mother to decide when she has reached her limit. A mama’s mental health trumps breastfeeding. Every time. Breastmilk does not care for, nurture and bond with the baby. A mother does. I am not arguing the health benefits of breastfeeding. Those are known facts. I am talking about the part that just isn’t talked about enough: a mom’s mental health.”

Bottle feeding moms:
  • Don’t make breastfeeding moms feel uncomfortable to breastfeed in front of you
  • Don’t say fed is best.  I know that technically it includes breastfeeding, but it is the counter to breast is best.  Let’s stop arguing about what is best and just feed our babies.
  • Do feed your baby in whatever way is best for your family, and know in your heart that whatever decision you make is the best decision.

If I have another baby (when my hubby reads this sentence, he is going to have a panic attack!), I will try to breastfeed again.  Not because I feel pressured to, but because it can be a beautiful thing when it works.  And if it doesn’t, I’m gonna whip out my Dr. Browns with pride.

I’d love to hear your (nonjudgy!) thoughts.  Did you struggle with twin breastfeeding or singleton breastfeeding? How did it make you feel?

The breast is best vs fed is best battle needs to end. I felt so much pressure to breastfeed my twins and struggled with a lot of guilt when it didn't work out. However you choose to feed your babies is the best choice for your family! #expectingtwins #breastfeeding #fedisbest #worldbreastfeedingweek #breastfeedingtwins

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Saturday 9th of December 2023

Wow, you don't know what your post has helped me, I just had 2 identical twins, they have been in NICU for 4 weeks, and I haven't stopped pumping and my supplement doesn't go down from 8 pum jokes and 2 power pomp I only reach 12ml it's very frustrating and painful, because I want to breastfeed my babies but it doesn't flow. So your words reach my soul.


Thursday 18th of March 2021

First time mom here to late preterm twin boys (born at 34+5). They are now 5 weeks old and I’ve yet to have a real successful breastfeeding session with either one. Because of their time in the NICU, the started on bottles (feeding tubes before that). I think because they were used to the instant gratification of the bottle, I found it really difficult for them to latch, which stressed them out and me out. We’ve continued to keep the boys on bottles (so my husband can also help feed). Trying to fit in pumping to provide them enough milk has been incredibly stressful for me. It seems like there isn’t enough time in the day to take care of them, pump, and try to take care of myself. Along with that, I have a severe slacker breast so my production is super low on one side. Reading this post made me feel better about being okay with more formula for my boys. The babies have to eat something, and if that’s formula, that’s okay! Thank you for your reassuring words.

Tips and Advice for Feeding Twins (BFBN Guest Post) — Christine Keys

Thursday 10th of August 2017

[…] Breastfeeding is something that didn’t work for me.  You can read more about my journey here. […]

Inez Bayardo

Saturday 22nd of April 2017

My issues with breastfeeding were pretty minor. My son did have oral thrush which was a major pain and pretty stressful at times but still a really small issue compared to what many other mamas go through.

Caitlin Rogers

Saturday 22nd of April 2017

I've heard thrush can be no fun!!

Thomas N Brittany Marshall

Friday 21st of April 2017

I struggled with breastfeeding all 4 of my kids. I generally only breastfeed for a couple weeks before I have to supplement due to lack of weight gain. I used to feel like such a failure for not being able to provide what they needed but I finally got past it. As long as they're healthy then I'm happy ?

Caitlin Rogers

Saturday 22nd of April 2017

Them gaining weight and being healthy and happy is the only thing that matters!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.